Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac's New Appraisal Independence Requirements: What Lenders Need to Know

Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac's New Appraisal Independence Requirements: What Lenders Need to Know

What Changed

Fannie Mae issued a clarification to their shared appraisal independence policy with Freddie Mac. The agencies now explicitly prevent LOs, brokers, and anyone compensated by loan volume from having any influence on the appraisal provider selection process.

What Lenders Can No Longer Do

  • Allow LOs (including third-party brokers) to pick AMCs on an order-by-order basis
  • Allow LOs to pick their favorite AMCs for broad order allocation
  • Allow anyone compensated based on loan volume/closed loans, or even managed by someone who is, to influence selection
  • Allow brokers to order directly from an AMC, even if approved by the wholesale lender

Lenders found in violation risk losing their "Seller" status or facing loan repurchase demands.

Why This Happened

These requirements aren't entirely new; the agencies never intended to allow LO selection workflows. But the previous policy language was vague enough that some lenders felt comfortable using them. LOs obviously want professional management of their orders, and leaders want to keep top producers happy.

How Reggora Ensures Compliance

Modern appraisal vendor management software like Reggora automatically ensures compliance through two configurable methods:

Option 1: Performance-Based Allocation

Automatically allocate orders based on the performance of your AMCs (turn time, revision rate, fee escalation rate). The Appraisal Marketplace is ideal for this approach.

Option 2: Custom Scoring Criteria

Automatically allocate orders based on custom criteria you define: by geography, weighted scoring, or other business rules.

Wholesale Compliance

Reggora also provides a compliant workflow for wholesale lenders. Brokers can order appraisals within your wholesale portal, with orders flowing through your automated allocation workflow.

Need help adjusting? Book a complimentary GSE appraisal compliance evaluation, even if you're not a Reggora client.

Related Posts

Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac's UAD 3.6 Policy Exception: What Lenders Need to Know
Policy & Compliance

Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac's UAD 3.6 Policy Exception: What Lenders Need to Know

What Is a Reconsideration of Value (ROV)? A Complete Guide for Lenders
Policy & Compliance

What Is a Reconsideration of Value (ROV)? A Complete Guide for Lenders

Webinar Replay: Adapting to the New Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD)
Policy & Compliance

Webinar Replay: Adapting to the New Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD)